(Permission is granted to redistribute this material as long as the Kollel header and the subscription info at the end are included.) |
brought to you by Kollel Iyun Hadaf of Har Nof
Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Email - daf@shemayisrael.co.il
_________________________________________________________________
Chagigah Chart #1
(A) BEIS HILLEL |
(B) BEIS SHAMAI |
||
---|---|---|---|
1) | CHAGIGAH OF THE 14TH OF NISAN |
even from Ma'aser(1) |
even from Ma'aser(1) |
2) | CHAGIGAH OF YOM TOV | from Chulin, but he may combine with Ma'aser Sheni(2)(4) |
Chulin(3) |
3) | SHALMEI SIMCHAH | even from Ma'aser(1)(4) |
even from Ma'aser(1)(4) |
4) | OLAS RE'IYAH | from Chulin | from Chulin |
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) It is permitted to bring the Chagigah of the 14th of Nisan and the
Shalmei Simchah from money of Ma'aser. This is because the Chagigah of the
14th is not obligatory, and any non-obligatory Korban may be brought from
money of Ma'aser. Likewise, Shalmei Simchah is not obligatory when a person
has meat of Shelamim to eat (RASHI DH Af Min ha'Ma'aser).
(2) The Amora'im dispute how this combination ("Tofel") is to be done:
1. Chizkiyah (8a) -- one may add additional *animals* of Ma'aser to the first animal, but the first animal must be from Chulin.(3) According to Beis Shamai, "Tefeilah" may not be done (in any of the above-mentioned manners, fn. 2); the entire animal must come completely from Chulin. (Why, though, does he prohibit adding animals of Ma'aser to the first animal, which comes from Chulin? Once he has brought the first animal, he has already fulfilled his obligation to bring the Korban Chagigah, and the subsequent animals are all Nedavos, which may come from Ma'aser! RASHI (8a, DH Chizkiyah Amar) answers that all of the animals that are brought on the first day have a status of the Korban Chagigah, and thus they must all be brought from Chulin.)
2. Rebbi Yochanan (8a) -- one may combine *money* of Ma'aser to *money* of Chulin in order to buy a larger animal for the Korban Chagigah (but *all* animals that are brought on the first day must have some Chulin money in them).
3. Rav Sheshes (8b) -- one may add additional *animals* of Ma'aser to the first animal, which is brought from Chulin (like Chizkiyah), *and*, even with that first animal, one may combine *money* of Ma'aser to money of Chulin to buy a larger animal (like Rebbi Yochanan).
Main Chagigah Page |
List of Charts and Graphics |
Insights to the Daf |
Background to the Daf |
Review the Daf Questions and Answers |
Point by Point Summary |