ANSWERS TO REVIEW QUESTIONS
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous daf Gitin 70
GITIN 70 - dedicated by Sandy and Les Wiesel in memory of Sandy's parents,
Rabbi Jonah and Lena Caplan.
(a) The cure for wet boils comprises seven fat wheat kernels, which one
roasts on the metal of a new hoe.
(b) Rav Shimi bar Ashi used this same cure to heal a Nochri of a different
illness - leprosy.
(c) There was no hope for someone who was pierced by a Persian spear -
because they would temper it with poison.
(d) They would administer juicy meat roasted on coal and wine to someone who
was pierced - to prolong his life for a sufficient period of time for him to
write his last will and testament (though it is unclear why they would not
have done so just for the sake of prolonging his life).
(a) The same is true of someone who swallowed a hornet, whom they would
administer - a Revi'is ha'Lug of strong vinegar, in order to prolong his
life, as they did in the previous case.
(b) Rebbi Yehoshua ben Levi said that someone who eats ox meat with turnip
and sleeps out in the moonlight on the night of the fourteenth or the
fifteenth of Tamuz - will contract a fever of the bones.
(c) The same will happen, says the Tana of a Beraisa, to someone who eats
his fill of any sweet food that he particularly likes.
(d) Rav Papa needs to add that this applies even to dates - in spite of Mar,
who said that dates satisfy, warm the body, clear one's bowels and
strengthen a person.
(a) Abaye, who teaches us the cure for a fever of the bones, quotes his
nurse, who taught him that it is different than all other cures in two ways.
Other cures must be taken for three, seven or twelve days on an empty
stomach. In contrast - one keeps on taking this cure until such time as he
is cured, and one takes it after having eaten and drunk, and after having
(b) The cure consists of Shesisa de'T'lafchi (a fistful of a dish made from
lentil-flour and salt), which one mixes - with a fistful of old wine.
(c) After that, he induces perspiration by wrapping himself in his sheet and
going to sleep.
(d) One should ...
1. ... not wake him up (but let him wake up by himself), because perspiring
is good for him.
2. ... take away his sheet, after he wakes up and arises, otherwise, the
illness is likely to recur.
(a) Eliyahu advised Rebbi Nasan that when he ate, he should eat a third,
drink a third and leave a third free - to allow for the possibility of his
becoming angry, which takes up the extra third (otherwise he is liable to
(b) The Tana advises one to avoid stomach problems by ...
1. ... dipping one's bread in vinegar and wine (rather than eating it dry).
(c) According to Mar Ukva, someone who drinks poor quality white wine (known
as 'Tiyla'), or someone who, according to Rav Chisda, sits by the fire on a
Nisan morning, and anoints himself with oil, before going out into the sun -
will become lethargic.
2. ... eating less that one's fill.
3. ... going to the bathroom as soon as one feels the urge to do so (and not
holding it back).
(d) According to Rav Chisda, there are sixty different kinds of wine, the
worst of which is Tiyla. The best is - red wine with a good smell.
(a) The Tana of a Beraisa says that if ...
1. ... one of the partners lets blood immediately prior to Tashmish - they
will have children who are lethargic.
(b) It is safe to perform Tashmish after blood-letting, says Rav Papa - as
long as he first ate something.
2. ... both of them do so - they will have children who are very weak, due
to an insect growing in the brain.
(c) Rabah bar Rav Huna says that someone who arrives from a long journey and
immediately performs Tashmish - will have children who are lethargic.
(d) The Tana of the Beraisa says that someone who performs Tashmish
immediately after leaving the bathroom - will have children who are
epileptics. It is only safe to do so after he has waited the time it takes
to walk half a Mil (nine minutes), because, otherwise, he is followed by the
demon who rules over the bathroom.
(a) Someone who performs Tashmish ...
1. ... standing - will suffer cramps.
(b) The cure for Dalarya, says Abaye, is a crocus that grew on a hedge.
Rav Papa would chew it and swallow it - Rav Papi used to chew it and spit it
2. ... sitting - will emit a lot of wind.
3. ... switching positions with his wife - will be struck with 'Dalarya'
(which is not explained).
(c) Abaye advises someone who is unable to perform Tashmish to take a Kapiza
(a vessel holding three Lugin) of Kurtami (safflower) that grew in earth
that was manured with sheep's dung (see Rashash) - which he then grinds
well, boils in wine and drinks.
(d) Rebbi Yochanan said - that this was what regained him his youthful
(a) Three things make a person weak: fear, travel - and sins.
(b) A second list of three things that make a person weak includes someone
who eats or drinks standing - or performs Tashmish standing.
(c) These same three things are also contained in a list of five things
that, if one stands immediately after performing them, are closer to death
than to life. The other two are - blood-letting and sleeping.
(a) Six things are listed as fatal: Someone who arrived from a journey and
immediately performs rigorous exercises, lets blood and enters the
bathhouse, drinks wine and becomes drunk. The last one is Tashmish on the
ground (if sleeping on the ground is a separate entity, then it is unclear
how the Tana arrives at the number 'six'). He is only in danger if he
actually performs them all.
(b) Rebbi Yochanan insists that he performs them in the right order, to
which Abaye adds - that if he does not, he will not die, but he will become
(c) We reconcile Rebbi Yochanan with the story of Me'uras, who did only
three of the six things with her slave, yet the slave died - by establishing
that he was a weak man to begin with.
(a) What the following things have in common ...
1. ... Travel, Tashmish, wealth, work, wine and sleep is - that a little of
them is good, whereas a lot is bad.
(b) The two that should be added to the first list - are hot water (for
bathing and drinking) and blood-letting.
2. ... Salt, hunger, Tzara'as, weeping and sleeping on the ground is - that
they diminish the Zera.
(c) The two foods that should be added to the second list are - coriander
(d) Blood-letting too, should be added to the second list to make up the
eight things. Rav Papa draws a distinction between letting blood from the
lower half of the body, which is twice as dangerous as all the other things
in the list, and the upper half, which will make him twice as healthy.
(a) We learned above that hops out of season are harmful. According to Rav
Papa - Teives is considered out of season for hops.
(b) And Tamuz - is considered in-season.
(c) The difference between hops in-season, and the other months of the year,
in this regard, is - that whereas hops in-season, are healthy, during the
other months, they have no effect whatsoever.
(a) We learned in our Mishnah that if a man appointed a Sheli'ach to write
his wife a Get, and after he has been seized by Kurdaikus he rescinds it,
the original Shelichus stands. According to Resh Lakish, we write the Get
immediately, according to Rebbi Yochanan - only after he recovers.
(b) Resh Lakish explains 'Ein Devarav ha'Acharonim K'lum' literally - Rebbi
Yochanan interprets it to mean - that, in spite of the cancellation, the
Sheli'ach will not need to be re-appointed following the husband's recovery.
(c) Resh Lakish compares Kurdaikus to someone who is asleep, Rebbi Yochanan
compares him to a Shoteh.
1. ... Rebbi Yochanan does not compare him to someone who is asleep -
because someone who is asleep will wake up automatically, whereas *he*
requires a cure.
2. ... Resh Lakish does not compare him to a Shoteh - because a Shoteh is
incurable, whereas *he* is curable.
(a) Rav Yehudah Amar Shmuel says that if someone whose two pipes (the
wind-pipe and the esophagus) or the majority of them, have been cut - hints
(see Tosfos DH 've'Ramaz') that one should write his wife a Get, one writes
it and gives it to her immediately.
(b) The Tana of the Beraisa says the same - about someone who has been badly
wounded or hanged.
(c) This is a Kashya on Rebbi Yochanan, who maintains that, if someone is
seized by Kurdaikus, one cannot give the Get that he appointed a Sheli'ach
to give, until he is cured - because, in the above cases, that would entail
writing and giving the woman a Get after her husband's death and would
contravene the rule 'Ein Get le'Achar Misah'.
(d) Rebbi Hoshaya explains - that Rebbi Yochanan concedes there that one
writes and gives the Get immediately, because whereas in those two cases,
the man may be weak physically, he is mentally strong, whereas in Rebbi
Yochanan's case, he has been affected mentally.
(a) Rav Yehudah Amar Shmuel said that if witnesses testified about the state
of that man - his wife is permitted to remarry.
(b) We nevertheless permit writing her a Get, because the reason that she is
permitted to remarry is - (not because he is presumed to be dead, but)
because he is on the verge of death (and as long as the Get is written
immediately, it is valid).
(c) The person who inadvertently dealt the stroke does not have to run into
exile - because of the likelihood that his actual death is caused either by
the wind or by his own gasping.
(d) The difference whether it was the wind that ultimately caused his death
or the dying man's own gasping will be - when the killing took place in a
marble house (where no wind enters) or where he did not gasp.
(a) We learned in our Mishnah that, if a dumb man nods his head a number of
times to different questions, we acknowledge his request to write his wife a
Get. We are not afraid that he has adopted a tendency to ...
1. ... say 'Yes' to everything or 'No' - because we alternate the questions
(e.g. one that requires an affirmative answer and one that requires a
(b) Tana de'Bei Rebbi Yishmael actually specifies the questions that one
asks him. Initially, when he says that we ask him about 'summer things in
the winter' and 'winter things in the summer', we think that he is referring
to clothes and suchlike (e.g. a coat in the summer, and thin sheets in the
2. ... alternate, once 'Yes' and once 'No' - because we ask him first a
question that requires an affirmative answer, then two that require a
negative one, and finally another question that requires an affirmative
answer, or vice-versa.
(c) We reject this suggestion however - on the grounds that he might just be
feeling cold in the summer or hot in the winter, in which case, his answers
do not reflect that he is demented.
(d) What he therefore means is - that we ask him whether he would like
summer fruits (such as cherries) in the winter and winter fruits (such as
medlars - a kind of sour apple) in the summer.