ANSWERS TO REVIEW QUESTIONS
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous daf Sanhedrin 92
SANHEDRIN 92 (7 Teves) - Dedicated by Josh Daniel of Efrat, Israel, in
memory of his brother, Yitzchok Yisroel [ben Refael Noach Yosef] Daniel, on
his Yahrzeit (7 Teves).
(a) Rav Sheishes says that someone who teaches Torah in this world - will
merit to teach it in Olam ha'Ba.
(b) He learns this from the Pasuk "u'Marveh Gam Hu Yoreh", which means -
either that 'like he satiated his Talmid, so he will *satiate* ... ', or
'like he *taught* him ... '.
(c) Rava learns Techi'as ha'Meisim from the Pasuk in Vayechi - and that is
what Ravina learns from the Pasuk "ve'Rabim mi'Yeshenei Admas Afar Yakitzu,
Eileh le'Chayei Olam ve'Eileh la'Charafos ... "?, and Rav Ashi from the
Pasuk "ve'Atah Lech le'Keitz, ve'Tanu'ach ve'Ta'amod le'Goralcha le'Keitz
(a) Rebbi Elazar says ...
1. ... that a leader who leads the community in a gentle manner in this
world - will merit to lead them in Olam ha'Ba.
(b) When Rav Ada Karchina'ah queried him from the Pasuk "Keil Nekamos Hashem
... " (and what is so great about vengeance?) Rebbi Elazar replied - that
vengeance too, is great in its context, as we shall now see from a statement
2. ... that "De'ah (Da'as)" is great - because it is placed between two
letters of Hashem's Name (or between two Names of Hashem, all of which are
wondrous) see Agados Maharsha.
3. ... the Beis-Hamikdash is great - because it (too) is placed between two
Names of Hashem.
(c) Ula explains the Pasuk "Keil Nekamos Hashem, Keil Nekamos Hofi'a" (as if
"Hofi'a" was written twice, once with each Nekamah) - once for good (that
Yisrael merited the revelation of the Shechinah, when they said 'Na'aseh
ve'Nishma'), and once for bad (to punish the nations, to whom He will reveal
himself on the Day of Judgment, in order to punish them for their misdeeds).
(d) Based on the fact that both De'ah and the Beis-Hamikdash are placed
between two names of Hashem, Rebbi Elazar stated - that anyone who reaches a
level of De'ah, it is as if the Beis-Hamikdash was built in his days.
(a) Rebbi Elazar learns from the Pasuk "u've'Da'as, Chadarim Yimle'u Kol Hon
Yakar ve'Na'im" - that someone who has De'ah will eventually become wealthy.
(b) And about someone who ...
1. ... does not have De'ah, he said - that it is forbidden to sympathize
(c) Rebbi Elazar also said that someone who does not ...
2. ... gives of his bread to someone who does not have De'ah, he said - will
be stricken with suffering.
1. ... have De'ah - will eventually go into exile.
(d) We reconcile this with Rebbi Elazar's own statement that if someone
leaves bread on the table it is as if he had served idols (because it was
the way of the worshippers of Gad to leave food on the table for him) - by
establishing the latter statement specifically when they brought a whole
bread to the table which they placed together with the left-over pieces.
2. ... study Torah at night-time - will be consumed by the fire of Gehinom.
3. ... benefit Talmidei-Chachamim with his money - will never see any sign
of B'rachah in his finances.
4. ... leave bread on the table after eating - will never see , any sign of
B'rachah in his finances either.
(a) When Rivkah ordered Ya'akov to go into Yitzchok for the B'rachos, he
initially declined on the grounds that his father would discover his real
identity "ve'Hayisi be'Einav ki'Mesa'te'a" (Toldos). Based on the Pasuk
"Hevel Heimah, Ma'aseh Ta'atu'im", Rebbi Elazar extrapolates from "ve'Hayisi
be'Einav ki'Mesa'te'a" - that when someone lies, it is as if he had
(b) And he says 'Kol ha'Mistakel be'Ervah, Kashto Nin'arah'. He might be
referring to someone who looks at a woman's Ervah - or he might be referring
to someone who thinks adulterous thoughts in connection with a married
(c) According to the first explanation, 'Kashto Nin'arah' means that his
Eiver Tashmish will become weak, and he will not be able to have children.
According to the second explanation, he means - that his strength will wane
(either from a Lashon of shaking out [like 'Matza K'sus, *Mena'arah*'], or
of drowning ["*va'Yena'er* Hashem es Mitzrayim"]).
(d) When Rebbi Elazar said 'Le'olam Hevei K'veil, ve'Kayam' - he was
advising anybody who wishes to live long, to make himself small (to be
humble "K'veil" literally means 'dark' [unseen]).
(e) Rebbi Zeira substantiated this with a Mishnah in Nega'im, which rules -
that if a dark room has a mark of Tzara'as, which needs to be examined, the
Kohen may not open a window to help him see better (so it remains Tahor).
The source for this Halachah is the word "ke'Nega Nir'ah *Li* ba'Bayis" from
which we derive by the Kohen's own eyesight, and not by means of other
sources of light).
(a) The Pasuk in Mishlei lists the grave, the womb and the earth - which
have in common the fact that none of them can ever get enough (of the dead,
Be'ilos, and water, respectively).
(b) The deeper connection that Rebbi Tavi Amar Rebbi Yashiyah discovers
between the grave and the womb is - that just as the latter takes in and
gives out, so too, does the grave (a further proof for Techi'as ha'Meisim).
(c) He derives from a 'Kal va'Chomer - that if the womb, despite the fact
that it takes in quietly (the Bi'ah), gives out with a lot of noise (the
birth of the baby), then the grave, which takes in with a lot of noise (the
burial), will certainly give out with a lot of noise (Techi'as ha'Meisim [as
the Pasuk writes "On that day, a big Shofar will be blown"]).
(a) Based on the word "Kadosh", which has connotations of permanence, Tana
de'Bei Eliyahu explains the Pasuk "ve'Hayah ha'Nish'ar be'Tziyon ve'ha'Nosar
bi'Yerushalayim Kadosh Ye'amer Lo" to mean - that once the Tzadikim come
back to life (before the official Techi'as ha'Meisim [see Rif in Ein
Ya'akov]), they will never again revert to dust.
(b) On the other hand, we learn from the Pasuk "ve'Nisgav Hashem Levado
ba'Yom ha'Hu" - that, some time between Mashi'ach and Techi'as ha'Meisim,
there will be one thousand years when Hashem will be alone in the world.
(c) The Tzadikim who will remain alive at that time - will float on top of
(d) This does not mean that they will suffer - for, as the Pasuk in Yeshayah
states, they will grow wings like eagles, and be granted extra strength so
as not to tire.
(a) When we ask why not learn from the dead whom Yechezkel brought back to
life, we mean to ask - why the Tana de'Bei Eliyahu does not learn from them
that Techi'as ha'Meisim is followed by death (see also Agados Maharsha).
(b) And we answer - that Tana de'Bei Eliyahu subscribes to the opinion that
the episode with Yechezkel was a Mashal which never really took place (as we
shall now see).
(c) Yechezkel prophesied - just before the Churban Bayis Rishon in Bavel,
where Nevuchadnetzar had exiled him together with Yechonyah eleven years
before the Churban. The Navi in Eretz Yisrael at that time was Yirmiyah.
(d) According to Rebbi Eliezer in that Beraisa, they sang 'Hashem Meimis be
be'Tzedek, u'Mechayeh be'Rachamim', whereas according to Rebbi Yehoshua,
they sang a part of Shiras Chanah - "Hashem Meimis u'Mechayeh, Morid She'ol
va'Ya'al" (as recorded in Shmuel).
(e) When Rebbi Yehudah said about the episode with Yechezkel 'Emes Mashal
Hayah' - he meant to say that in truth, it is no more than a parable.
(a) The most interesting explanation of all is that of Rebbi Eliezer the son
of Rebbi Yossi Hagelili, who says - that, following their revival, those who
came back to life arose and went up to Eretz Yisrael, where they married and
(b) When Rebbi Yehudah ben Beseira heard this, he stood up and declared -
that he was a descendant of theirs, and that the Tefilin he was wearing was
handed down to him from his ancestors, which they actually wore.
(c) According to Rav, the dead that Yechezkel brought back to life were the
B'nei Ephrayim - who reckoned the four hundred years of Galus Mitzrayim from
the B'ris Bein ha'Besarim (instead of from the birth of Yitzchak thirty
years later), and who therefore left Egypt thirty years too early. They
marched up to Eretz Yisrael intending to capture it, but were killed on the
way by the men of Gas (one of the cities of the P'lishtim).
(d) Their father (Ephrayim) mourned for them for a long time (and his
relatives and friends came to comfort him).
(a) Shmuel is of the opinion that the dead that Yechezkel revived were
people who had not believed in Techi'as ha'Meisim, and who said "Yavshu
Atzmoseinu ... ". Rebbi Yirmiyah bar Aba, based on the Pasuk "ha'Atzamos
ha'Yeveishos Shim'u D'var Hashem", says - that they were people totally
devoid of Mitzvos.
(b) Rebbi Yitzchak Nafcha explains that they were people who had filled the
Heichal with Shekatzim u'Remasim (vermin and insects). The final opinion is
that of Rebbi Yochanan, who maintains - that they were the dead of the
valley of Dura, whom Nevuchadnetzar had killed after leading them into exile
from Eretz Yisrael.
(c) The special feature that marked those young exiles - was their beautiful
(d) In fact, Nevuchadnetzar ...
1. ... killed them - because their beauty caused the Kasdian (Babylonian)
women to break out into Ziyvus.
2. ... trample them after they were already dead - in order to distort their
features, because that trend continued whenever the women saw them, even
after they were dead.
(a) According to the Beraisa, Hashem instructed Yechezkel to revive the dead
of Bik'as Dura - to coincide with Nevuchadnetzar casting Chananyah, Mishael
and Azaryah into the furnace.
(b) The first thing the bones did was to tap Nevuchadnetzar on his face.
According to the other version - it was the drinking vessels that he had
manufactured out of some of those bones that tapped him on the mouth as he
was about to drink from them.
(c) When Nevuchadnetar asked what was going on, he was told that the
colleague of the men whom he had cast into the furnace was about to revive
the dead in Bik'as Dura (see Agados Maharsha).
(d) We refer to Nevuchadnetzar as 'Shachik Tamya' - because those words mean
the grinder of bones, which describes what he did to the bones under
(a) When Nevuchadnetzar began relating Hashem's miracles and praising His
Kingdom - an angel came and slapped him across the mouth.
(b) Had the angel not stopped him, says Rebbi Yitzchak, he would have made
all the praises of David ha'Melech in Seifer Tehilim appear insignificant
(and people would have begun to recite his praises of Hashem instead of
(c) The Beraisa lists six miracles that occurred on that day. The first of
them was that the sunken furnace floated to the surface, and the last,
Yechezkel's revival of the dead. Besides the breaching of the furnace's
walls and the depleted pride of Nevuchadnetzar - the golden image that
Nevuchadnetzar had set up in the valley of Dura fell on its face and the
kings who helped Nevuchadnetzar to throw the Tzadikim into the furnace, were
burned (in their place).
(a) We might also read 'Humak Suro' (the depletion of Nevuchadnetzar's
pride) - as 'Humak Sido' which means that the lime melted.
(b) The purpose of ...
1. ... the breaching of the walls of the furnace was - so that the people
would be able to see the miracle that was taking place inside.
(c) Four kings were burned together with their retinue, and we know that
from the fact that although the Pasuk initially mentions the seven rulers
that Nevuchadnetzar initially gathered, only three are mentioned after
Chananyah, Misha'el and Azaryah emerged from the furnace.
2. ... the lime melting was - for the heat of the flowing lime to kill the
kings who had helped Nevuchadnetzar to throw the three Tzadikim into the
(d) We learn from the fact, that Chananel, Mishael and Azaryah dressed in
their best clothes (as the Pasuk relates) before being cast into the
furnace - that even whilst being punished, one should, as far as possible,
retain one's dignity and status, so that the enemy should feel embarrassed
(see also Agados Maharsha).