ANSWERS TO REVIEW QUESTIONS
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous dafYoma 87
YOMA 59-88 have been dedicated to the memory of the late Dr. Simcha
Bekelnitzky (Simcha Gedalya ben Shraga Feibush) of Queens N.Y. by his wife
and daughters. Well known in the community for his Chesed and Tzedakah, he
will long be remembered.
(a) When Rava saw a large group of people following him in reverence -
woried that it might go to his head, he quoted a Pasuk in Iyov, which warns
a person who becomes conceited that in the end, he will become
(b) Mar Zutra the Chasid reacted in the same way - when in his old age, they
carried him on their shoulders (in a sedan-chair) through the Beis-
Hamedrash, so that the people should not have to get up to make way for him.
(c) It is not good for the Resha'im when they *are* favored in this world,
and it is good for the Tzadikim when they are *not*.
1. Ach'av was favored when his entire family was destined to be wiped out
following the killing of Navos at his instigation. However, because he
humbled himself when he heard the news - the tragedy was postponed; it would
occur, not in his days, but in the days of his son.
2. Moshe, on the other hand, was not favored - when Hashem decreed that,
because of what he did by the rock, he would not enter Eretz Yisrael - and
no amount of pleading was able to change the decree.
(a) The benefits of Tzadikim not living as long as they deserve - are
enjoyed by their children and their descendants.
(b) Aharon's two remaining sons (Elazar and Isamar) did not die at the same
time as their brothers - due to the merits of Aharon (see Agados Maharsha).
(c) Many sons of Cana'an might have reached the level of Tavi, Raban
Gamliel's famous slave. They not, in fact, make it - due to the wickedness
of their grandfather, Cana'an.
(d) Someone who causes the community ...
1. ... to do good will not be tempted to sin (Hashem will remove the
temptation from his path - though this does not mean that he will not sin if
he so wishes) - because it is unfair that his disciples should sit in Gan
Eden, whilst he sits in Gehinom. (Alternatively, his deeds will not lead
others to sin, for the same reason).
2. ... to sin - will not be given the opportunity to do Teshuvah - because
it is unfair that he should sit in Gan Eden whilst his disciples sit in
(a) 'ha'Omer Echta ve'Ashuv, Echta ve'Ashuv Ein Maspikin ... '. The Tana
repeats the words 'Echta ve'Ashuv' - like Rav Huna Amar Rav, who says that
it is only after the *second* time that one has sinned that he considers it
to be permitted (and will not therefore do a sincere Teshuvah on it), but
not after the *first*.
(b) Our Mishnah says that Yom Kipur will not atone for someone who
deliberately sins, whilst relying on Yom Kipur to atone for it - a fact with
which even Rebbi will agree, due to the fact that he is using Yom Kipur as
an excuse to sin.
(c) Sins between man and man cannot be forgiven unless one makes up with the
person whom one has wronged. The Pasuk ...
1. ... "Im Yecheta Ish le'Ish ... u'Filelo Elokim" means - that he will be
forgiven only the judges find him guilty and make him pay his debt at least,
that is how we initially explain it).
(d) One Jew who wronged another monetarily, must make up to him by paying
him back. If he wronged him with words - he must make up to him by appeasing
2. ... "ve'Im la'Hashem Yecheta Ish, Mi *Yispalel* Ba'ado" - cannot mean
"Who will judge him?" since Hashem is not short of Sheluchim to punish the
man who has sinned against Him. It must therefore be an expression of
appeasement, and this what the Pasuk is therefore saying: "If someone sins
against his friend and appeases him, Hashem will forgive him, whereas if he
sins against Hashem, who will appease Hashem (other than Teshuvah and good
(a) If the wronged person does not accept the sinner's request to pardon him
- then he is obligated to approach him three times, each time with three
friends, to help pacify him for what he did.
(b) Rebbi Yossi b'Rebbi Chanina comments - that it is even *forbidden* to
make more than three attempts at reconciliation.
(c) If the person whom one wronged with words has died - he takes ten men to
his graveside and begs him for forgiveness.
(a) Rebbi Yirmiyah went to Rebbi Aba to appease him for some wrong that he
had done him, and whilst he was waiting for Rebbi Aba to exit, Rebbi Aba's
maidservant inadvertently poured some sewage on his head. That is when he
quoted the Pasuk in Tehilim "me'Ashpos Yarim Evyon".
(b) When Rebbi Aba heard Rebbi Yirmiyah quoting the Pasuk, he went out to
see him, and reasily forgave him for what he had done.
(c) When someone wronged Rebbi Zeira verbally, he would go and stand in
front of him, to make it easy for him to ask him for forgiveness (a crucial
part of Teshuvah).
(a) Rav Huna told his Rebbe, Rav, that he was on his way to kill someone -
because he knew that the butcher who had wronged Rav, would not respond in a
positive way, thereby making his situation in Heaven worse (Note: It is the
same with us during the ten days between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kipur, when
Hashem avils Himself to us to facilitate Teshuvah. If we fail to respond, we
make our situation worse on Yom Kipur).
(b) His prediction come true - when the butcher, looking up and seeing Rav
standing in front of him, told him to leave, since he had nothing to do with
(c) The butcher was chopping meat; a bone flew up and entered his throat,
(a) Rav was learning a chapter in T'nach in front of Rebbi. He started again
from the beginning when Rebbi Chiya arrived, and a third time for Bar
Kapara. But when Rebbi Chanina b'Rebbi Chama joined the group he declined to
start all over again, so he just continued, much to Rebbi Chanina's disgust.
So he went to plead with him for forgiveness on thirteen consecutive Erev
(b) In spite of what we learned earlier that it is forbidden to ask for
forgiveness more than three times - Rav took a strict line and went beyond
the letter of the law. (It is difficult to understand however, how Rav could
do this, seeing as Rebbi Yossi b'Rebbi Chanina specifically *forbade* it? -
According to Rabeinu Chananel, Rav acted in this way, because Rebbi Chanina
was his Rebbe, and the restriction of three times does not apply to someone
who has wronged one's Rebbe).
(c) Someone who readily forgives those who have sinned against him - will
find that Hashem will give him the same treatment: all his sins will be
(d) Rebbi Chanina did not forgive Rav - because he had a dream, in which
they suspended Rav on a date-palm (a sign that one will rise to greatness).
Since *he* was due to become Rebbi's successor, he was afraid that if Rav
were to remain in Eretz Yisrael, *he* would become the Rosh Yeshivah, which,
due to the principle 'One Malchus cannot encroach on another' would have
meant that he would have to die (in order to make room for Rav).
Consequently, his refusal to accept appeasement was an attempt to force Rav
to leave Eretz Yisrael, to become the Rosh Yeshivah in Bavel (which he
(a) The first recital of Viduy falls due on Yom Kipur - immediately after
the Se'udah ha'Mafsekes, as soon as one has brought in the fast (still
(b) Chazal instituted the recital of Viduy *before* the Se'udah ha'Mafsekes
to preempt the Satan (who is more than keen that one should not recite Viduy
and do Teshuvah), to prevent him from causing a person to choke during the
Se'udah (before one has had a chance to recite Viduy even once).
(c) One nevertheless needs to recite it again after the Se'udah - in case
one sinned in some way during the Se'udah.
(d) After the Se'udah, one subsequently recites Viduy ten times, twice
during each of the Tefilos. It is recited ...
- ... by the community - at the *end* of each Tefilah.
- ... by the Chazen - in the *middle*.
(a) We insert most of the Tefilos cited in the Gemara into our Tefilah, such
as 'Atah Yode'a Razei Olam' and 'Ki ba'Yom ha'Zeh Yechaper Aleichem'.
According to Rebbi Chanina, we should say 'Elokai ad she'Lo Notzarti Eini
Kedai ... ', which we also include in our Viduy. Rava used to say this the
whole year round.
(b) When the Shatz arrived at 'Aval Anachnu Chatanu' - Shmuel used to stand
erect (from the bowing position in which one recites Viduy).
(c) We learn from this that 'Aval Anachnu Chatanu' (*we* insert the word '
Anachnu *va'Avoseinu*') is the main Viduy (and the rest is not of great
importance - like Rebbi Akiva, who holds [on Daf 86b] that it is not
necessary to list one's sins).
(a) The three occasions on which, according to the Mishnah in Ta'anis, the
Kohanim would Duchan four times a day are - on a Ta'anis Tzibur (when there
is no rain), on the Ma'amados (on the four days each week when the men of
the Mishmar who were fasting, would gather in the various towns and read
from Bereishis) and on Yom Kipur.
(b) The four times are Shachris, Musaf, Minchah and Ne'ilah, which they
would Daven on the two former occasions. On a Ta'anis, there was no Musaf -
and what the Tana means is that at every (day) Tefilah, the Kohanim would
(c) The Mishnah is teaching us that, due to the fact that they were fasting,
the Kohanim would Duchen then even at Minchah (whereas throughout the year,
due to the possibility of drunkenness, there is no Duchening at Minchah.
(d) According to Rav, Ne'ilah comprises the extra Tefilah that we Daven at
the conclusion of the day; According to Shmuel, it is 'Mah Anu, Meh Chayeinu
... ' (like we say in Shachris every morning) - without a Berachah.
(a) Each Tefilah on Yom Kipur comprises seven Berachos.
(b) In fact, the Beraisa (which includes Ne'ilah in the list of Tefilos) is
a disproof to Shmuel; we make no effort to reconcile it with his opinion
(according to the Bach's text).
(c) According to the Tana Kama of the Beraisa, the middle Berachah of
Ne'ilah concludes 'ha'Keil ha'Solchan'. The Chachamim hold that although
that is an optional conclusion, the regular conclusion is 'Mekadesh
(d) 'Ne'ilah' could mean the closing of the Gates of Heaven - it could also
mean the closing of the gates of the Azarah.
(a) The Chazan whom Rava commended - began Ne'ilah with 'Ata Bechartanu',
and concluded it with 'Mah Anu, Meh Chayeinu ...'.
(b) Rav Nasan the father of Rav Huna Brei de'Rav Nasan said that every
individual should say 'Mah Anu ... ' after his Tefilah (See Tosfos
(a) Rav said that Ne'ilah covers Ma'ariv, which one is therefore exempt from
having to Daven.
(b) Rav himself rules that Ma'ariv is voluntary (and may therefore be
omitted anyway) - and his above statement is according to those who hold
that Ma'ariv is obligatory.
(c) Rav concedes that the Tana'im in the Beraisa, who discuss both Ne'ilah
and Ma'ariv, hold that Ma'ariv is obligatory - which, in his opinion, is a
(d) According to Rebbi Chanina ben Gamliel, one is obligated to Daven the
full Shemoneh-Esrei for Ma'ariv - the Tana Kama holds that one Davens seven
Berachos, the first three, the last three, and 'Havineinu' (an abridged
combination of the middle Berachos). The reason for this leniency is due to
'Tircha de'Tzibura' (easing the community's burden - see also Tosfos