by Dr. Avigdor Bonchek
Back to this week's Parsha | Previous Issues
And on its lower hem, you shall make pomegranates of blue wool, dark red wool and crimson wool, on its lower hem around. And bells of gold in their midst all around. A gold bell and pomegranate, a gold bell and a pomegranate on the lower hem of the robe all around.
And bells of gold: Rashi Bells together with their clappers in them.
In their midst all around: Rashi: Between them all the way around. Between every two pomegranates there was one bell attached and hanging from the hem of the robe.
A gold bell and a pomegranate, a gold bell and a pomegranate: Rashi: Next to it.
WHAT IS RASHI SAYING?
Thai is a typical Type II comment. Rashi weaves his words in between the Torah's words. It's purpose is to dispel a wrong understanding of the verse. Which misunderstanding? Your Answer:
A POSSIBLE MISUNDERSTANDING An Answer: Were the bells inside these woolen pomegranates or were they placed, each one, in between the pomegranates on the hem of the garment? Rashi sates his view clearly - the bells were on the hem in between the pomegranates. They were not within each of the pomegranates.
This view is not held by all commentators. The Ramban, for example, disagrees with Rashi and says that the bells were, in fact, placed within the pomegranates themselves.
What evidence would you cite to support Rashi's view? Hint: See the surrounding verse.
SUPPORT FOR RASHI'S VIEW
An Answer: Look at verse 28:35. When the Torah speaks of this robe with its bells and pomegranates it says: "… and its sound shall be heard when he comes into the Holy place which is before Hashem and when he goes out so that he shall not die.
Certainly if we want the sound of the bells to be heard, it would be best to have them hanging out in the open. Were they placed inside the woolen pomegranates their sound would be muffled. This seems to support Rashi's view of the position of the bells over that of the Ramban.
"What's Bothering Rashi?" is a production of "The Institute for the Study of Rashi."
The Institute is dedicated to the production of Torah material to enhance the appreciation of the Written Torah's sublime wisdom. Readers interested in sponsorship of this work are encouraged to contact us for further details at email@example.com
This article is provided as part of Shema Yisrael Torah Network
For information on subscriptions, archives, and