(Permission is granted to redistribute this material as long as the Kollel
header and the subscription info at the end are included.)

_________________________________________________________________
CHARTS FOR LEARNING THE DAILY DAF

brought to you by Kollel Iyun Hadaf of Har Nof
Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Email - daf@shemayisrael.co.il
_________________________________________________________________

Kesuvos Chart #14

Kesuvos Daf 93a

THE AMOUNTS COLLECTED BY THREE WIVES WITH
THREE KESUVOS WITH DIFFERENT VALUES
FROM LIMITED ASSETS OF THEIR HUSBAND
  (A)
THE WIFE WITH A 100-ZUZ KESUVAH 		(B)
THE WIFE WITH A 200-ZUZ KESUVAH		 (C)
THE WIFE WITH A 300-ZUZ KESUVAH
REBBI NASAN (OUR
MISHNAH) ACCORDING
TO SHMUEL
1) HUSBAND LEAVES
200 ZUZ, NORMAL
COLLECTION(1)
  1a) FIRST 100 33 1/3 33 1/3 33 1/3
  2a) SECOND 100 0 50 50
2) HUSBAND LEAVES
200 ZUZ, SECOND
WIFE (B) SAYS TO
FIRST WIFE (A):
"I HAVE NO ISSUE
TO TAKE UP WITH YOU"
  2a) FIRST 100 50 25(2) 25
  2b) SECOND 100 0 50 50
3) HUSBAND LEAVES
300 ZUZ, NORMAL
COLLECTION
  3a) FIRST 100 33 1/3 33 1/3 33 1/3
  3b) SECOND 100 0 50 50
  3c) THIRD 100 0 0 100
4) HUSBAND LEAVES
300 ZUZ, THIRD
WIFE (C) SAYS TO
FIRST AND SECOND
WIVES: "I HAVE NO
ISSUE TO TAKE UP
WITH YOU"
  4a) FIRST 100 50 50 0
  4b) SECOND 100 0 50 50
  4c) THIRD 100 0 0 100
REBBI NASAN (OUR
MISHNAH) ACCORDING
TO RAVINA
5) HUSBAND LEAVES
75 ZUZ, AND ANOTHER
125 ZUZ LATER FALLS
TO HIS ESTATE
  5a) FIRST 75 25 25 25
  5b) NEXT 75 25 25 25
  5c) NEXT 50 0 25 25
6) HUSBAND LEAVES
75 ZUZ, AND ANOTHER
225 ZUZ LATER FALLS
TO HIS ESTATE
  6a) FIRST 75 25 25 25
  6b) NEXT 75 25 25 25
  6c) NEXT 100 0 50 50
  6d) NEXT 50 0 0 50
REBBI'S OPINION(3)
7) REBBI: KEUSVAH
IS ALWAYS SPLIT
EQUALLY (UNLIKE
OUR MISHNAH)
  7a) HUSBAND LEAVES
100 ZUZ 		33 1/3 33 1/3 33 1/3
  7b) HUSBAND LEAVES
200 ZUZ 		66 2/3 66 2/3 66 2/3
  7c) HUSBAND LEAVES
300 ZUZ		 100 100 100
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) This, the most simple case, is not discussed in the Mishnah, since it can be inferred from the cases which the Mishnah teaches (Ritva).
(2) See Insights.
(3) This is the way RASHI explains the opinion of Rebbi who says that the assets "are divided equally." According to TOSFOS and the other Rishonim, though, when Rebbi says that the assets "are divided equally," he is saying that the assets are divided proportionately among the women relative to the lien that each one has on the assets. Hence, when there are 200 Zuz, the first wife (A) collects 33 1/3, the second wife (B) collects 66 2/3, and the third wife (C) collects 100, such that each of them collect 1/3 of their debt. Likewise, when there are 300 Zuz, the first wife (A) collects 50, the second wife (B) collects 100, and the third wife (C) collects 150, such that each of them collect 1/2 of their debt.

Main
Kesuvos Page		 List of Charts
and Graphics		 Insights
to the Daf
 Background
to the Daf		 Review the Daf
Questions and Answers 		Point by Point
Summary

For questions or sponsorship information, write to daf@shemayisrael.co.il