Parshas Yisro
The Midrash says, when Klal Yisroel stood at Har Sinai, Hashem presented the Torah to
each person at a level they could accept. After the first two dibros were delivered,
another midrash explains, the soul of each person standing there departed because they
could not tolerate such an exalted level of spirituality. These two Midrashim appear to
contradict each other.
The 49 days that led up to Matan Torah at Har Sinai were set aside for each Jew to
develop individually, creating a foundation for themselves. The foundation defines a
framework on which an edifice can be constructed. Each Jew developed his in preparation
for receiving the Torah but when the blue prints for the rest of the building were
delivered at Har Sinai they found it overwhelming. Hashem architected those blue prints to
match each persons unique foundation and so lead them each to greatness. Greatness,
though, is not a label assigned to a person; it is an achievement. Hashem expected them to
erect their own structure for Torah life on the foundations they had created.
Unfortunately Klal Yisroel felt overwhelmed when faced with the actual building of their
structures and requested Moishe Rabeinu to do it for them.
A little pipul from the Kli Chemda:
The Ramban in his Sefer Hamitzvohs counts Kibud Av VaAim (honor your father and
mother) as two separate mitzvohs. The gemara states, that three mitzvos where presented to
Klal Yisroel at Mara: Shabbos, Kibud Av VaAim, and Dinim (judges).
This seems to indicate that Kibud Av VaAim is considered one mitzvah which is in conflict
with the Ramban.
The mitzvah of Kibud Av VaAim is actually two mitzvohs; respecting ones mother
and respecting the person who is determined to be ones father by halacha. The
determination of ones father in halacha is accomplished using the law of Rove
(majority). Based on majority, the odds are, a mother s child is from her current
husband. Like all halachos in the Torah, it is only applicable to jews. In Mara, Bnei
Yisroel had not yet received the Torah and were considered gentiles, so this law did not
apply. Since there was no law to determine the status of father prior to Matan
Torah, there could be no independent mitzvah of honoring ones father. Therefore,
when the gemara enumerates the three mitzvohs presented in Mara, it is counted as a single
mitzvah.